Beyond Training: Forming Coaches Who Form Athletes

Beyond Training: Forming Coaches Who Form Athletes

Written by Dr. Trent Roose

 

Coaching Is More Than Training 

 

What if the most important thing a coach does never appears on the scoreboard?

Coaches spend hours teaching skills, developing game plans, preparing athletes, and pursuing championships. These responsibilities are important. Athletes need coaches who understand their sport and know how to help them improve on and off the field. But coaching has never been limited to training athletes to perform better. Every coach has the opportunity to form people. 

The way a coach responds to a mistake teaches an athlete how to respond to failure. The way a coach handles a hard conversation teaches an athlete about conflict. The way a coach treats an official, opponent, or team communicates to an athlete about respect. Even the way a coach responds to winning and losing can shape an athlete’s understanding of success, identity, and worth. 

 

This idea is connected to the biblical model of leadership. Paul tells Timothy, “Set an example of believers in speech, in conduct, in love, in faith and in purity” (1 Timothy 4:12). Paul understood that leadership is not telling people what to do. It is about showing them how to live. 

 

This is true in athletics. Coaches have the opportunity to influence how athletes think, respond, lead, serve, and relate to others. The lessons athletes carry with them after their playing days are not the drills or plays they learned, but the lessons about life they experienced through their coaches. Athletics can be a powerful context for development. 

The question, then, is not whether coaches are forming athletes. They are. The question is: What are they forming them into?

Coaches Are Formers, Whether They Intend to Be or Not

Athletes are constantly watching their coaches. 

They watch how coaches respond when a game is not going as planned. They noticed how coaches treat officials, respond to mistakes, handle conflict, and interact with athletes who may not receive much playing time. Athletes observe whether a coach’s actions match the standards and characteristics they expect from others. 

Jesus recognized the power of this influence when He said, “The student is not above the teacher, but everyone who is fully trained will be like their teacher:” (Luke 6:40). Athletes learn from what a coach says, but they are also shaped by who that coach is. 

 

A coach may never formally teach a lesson on humility, perseverance, accountability, or respect, yet athletes learn these lessons through observation and experience. A coach who demands accountability but refuses to acknowledge personal mistakes teaches one lesson. A coach who owns a mistake and models accountability teaches another.

Paul’s words in 1 Corinthians 11:1 capture this responsibility: “Follow my example, as I follow the example of Christ.” Christian coaching should point athletes beyond the coach and toward Christ. Coaches have an opportunity to model humility, sacrifice, service, integrity, and love.

 

Because coaching is inherently formative, developing coaches must involve more than technical expertise. If coaches are shaping athletes every day, then we must intentionally form coaches who can intentionally form people.

 

Coach Formation Must Come Before Athlete Formation 

If we want coaches to intentionally form athletes, then we must first be willing to intentionally form coaches. Coach development cannot stop with learning new strategies, attending clinics, or completing required certifications. Those things have value, but effective coaching requires more than technical knowledge.

Jesus’ words in Luke 6:40 remind us that “everyone who is fully trained will be like their teacher.” If athletes are becoming like the people who lead them, then the development of those leaders matters.

 

Coaches need opportunities to grow as leaders and as people. They need to develop their communication, emotional intelligence, conflict management, decision-making, and ability to build meaningful relationships. They also need space to reflect on their own leadership. What are they modeling? How do they respond under pressure? Are they creating an environment where athletes can grow?

This requires athletic departments to view coach development as an ongoing responsibility rather than a one-time event. Coaches should receive feedback, encouragement, mentorship, and opportunities to learn from others.

We cannot expect coaches to consistently give athletes what they have not developed themselves. If we want coaches who form athletes well, we must first invest in forming coaches well.

 

Moving From Professional Development to Personal Formation 

There is an important difference between professional development and personal formation.

Professional development often asks, “What do I need to learn to become better at my job?” Personal formation asks a deeper question: “Who am I becoming?”

 

Both questions matter. Coaches need to improve their knowledge and skills, but they also need to examine the person behind the position. A coach can become more organized, communicate more effectively, and develop better practices while still struggling with pride, impatience, insecurity, or a need for control.

Formation requires intentional reflection. Coaches need opportunities to consider how their values are reflected in their leadership and how their behavior affects the people they lead.

 

This might include regular self-assessment, leadership evaluations, mentoring relationships, peer conversations, or intentional reflection following difficult situations. These practices help coaches move beyond simply acquiring information toward actually growing as leaders.

Paul writes in Romans 12:2 about being transformed by the renewing of our minds. Formation is ultimately about transformation. It is an ongoing process of becoming more like Christ and allowing that transformation to influence how we lead others.

 

When coaches commit to their own formation, they become better equipped to help athletes grow. The goal is not simply better coaches. The goal is coaches who are becoming the kind of people who can help others become who they were created to be.

 

What Formational Coaching Looks Like

Formational coaching recognizes that athletes are more than performers. They are whole people who are developing physically, mentally, relationally, and spiritually.

Physically, coaches help athletes develop skills, strength, discipline, and healthy habits. But formation goes beyond physical ability. Athletes also need to learn how to respond to adversity, handle failure, manage pressure, and persevere when things do not go their way.

 

Relationally, athletics provides countless opportunities to teach communication, teamwork, accountability, conflict resolution, and respect. Coaches can help athletes understand that how they treat teammates, opponents, officials, and others matters.

Perhaps most importantly, coaches can help athletes develop character. Humility, integrity, responsibility, courage, and service are not simply qualities that matter away from athletics. They should be evident within athletics as well.

 

For Christian coaches, this formation points toward Christ. Colossians 3:17 reminds us, “Whatever you do, whether in word or deed, do it all in the name of the Lord Jesus.” Athletics becomes an opportunity to help athletes understand that their identity is not found in their statistics, playing time, championships, or athletic ability.

Formational coaching does not mean lowering expectations or caring less about winning. It means pursuing excellence while recognizing that the athlete is more important than the outcome.

The goal is not simply to produce better athletes. It is to help develop people who are prepared to use what they have learned in athletics to serve and lead others long after their playing careers are over.

The Institution’s Responsibility 

Coach formation cannot rest entirely on individual coaches. Athletic departments and institutions have a responsibility to create environments where coaches can grow.

What an institution consistently prioritizes, measures, rewards, and models communicates what it truly values. If an athletic department says character and development matter but only celebrates wins, coaches will naturally feel pressure to prioritize results above everything else.

 

Institutions can support coach formation by establishing clear expectations, providing meaningful professional development, creating opportunities for mentorship, and developing systems for regular feedback and evaluation.

Leadership must also model what it expects from coaches. If we want coaches who pursue growth, leaders should pursue growth. If we want coaches who value relationships, leaders should value relationships. If we want coaches who serve others, leaders must demonstrate servant leadership themselves.

 

This creates a culture where development is not viewed as another task on an already crowded schedule, but as part of the responsibility of leading people.

A healthy athletic department understands that investing in coaches is an investment in athletes. When coaches are growing, athletes are more likely to grow. When coaches are healthy, reflective, humble, and intentional, they are better equipped to create environments where athletes can flourish.

 

The culture we create for coaches will become part of the culture coaches create for athletes.

 

Conclusion – Coaches Who Form Athletes 

Athletics will always involve training. Athletes need to become stronger, faster, smarter, and more skilled. But the work of coaching is bigger than performance.

Every coach is forming athletes through what they teach, what they model, and how they lead.

 

The challenge for athletic departments is to move beyond simply training coaches to coach better. We must intentionally form coaches who understand the responsibility and opportunity they have to shape people.

Because when we form better coaches, we create coaches who can form better athletes—and ultimately better people.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *